Postby S_Walch » Sun May 20, 2018 8:32 pm
Okay, finally had time to get this done. So here we go (just regarding ובכל):
Places where the DSS is not extant at all
Ge 7:21; 8:17; 9:2, 10; 41:54; Ex 35:31; Le 18:23; 20:25; 25:24; Nu 21:25; Dt 4:29; 6:22; 16:15; 26:16; 30:2; Jos 9:1; 12:5; 22:5; 23:14; 24:17; Jdg 7:22; 11:26; 14:3;1 Sa 14:15; 17:12; 1 Ki 2:4; 8:48; 9:19; 2 Ki 20:13; 23:3, 25; 1 Ch 5:16; 2 Ch 6:38; 8:6; 11:12; 15:12, 15; 21:14; 28:25; 31:21; 34:31; Ne 9:10; 10:1; 13:6; Esther 2:11; 4:3; 8:17; Pr 4:7; Job 31:12; Eze 7:18; 23:7; 27:22, 27; 31:12; 34:13; Da 11:43; Je 32:41; 33:12; 51:52; 10:7 15:13; Mal 1:11;
Places where the DSS has a verse extant, but not all of it that has what we want in question
Ge 1:26: Some of verse extant in 4QGenb, 4QGend, & 4QGenk, but not of ובכל.
Ge 1:28: Some of verse extant in 4QGenb, 4QGenk, & pap4QGen, but not of ובכל.
Ex 1:14: Some of verse extant in 2QExoda & 4QGen-Exoda, but not of ובכל
Ex 7:29: Some of verse extant in 4QExodj & 4QPaleoExodm, but not of ובכל.
Ex 8:20: Some of verse extant in 4QGen-Exoda, 4QpaleoGen-Exodl & 4QpaleoExodm, but not of ובכל.
Ex 12:12: Some of verse extant in 4QpaleoGen-Exodl & 4QExodc, but not of ובכל.
Ex 31:3: Some of verse extant in 4QpaleoExodm, but not of ובכל.
Dt 6:5: Some of verse extant in 4QDeutp, but not of ובכל.
Dt 11:13: Some of this verse extant in 4QDeutc, 4QDeutj & 4QDeutk1, but not of ובכל.
Dt 13:4: Some of verse extant in 1QDeuta, but not of ובכל.
Dt 14:26: Some of verse extant in 1QDeuta & 4QpaleoDeutr, but not of ובכל.
Dt 15:10: Some of verse extant in 4QpaleoDeutr, but not of ובכל.
Dt 28:8: Some of verse extant in 4QDeutc, but not of ובכל.
Dt 30:6: Some of verse extant in 4QDeutb, but not of ובכל.
Dt 30:10: Some of verse extant in 4QDeutb, but not of ובכל.
Ps 135:9: Some of verse extant in 4QPsn, but not of ובכל.
Am 5:16: Some of verse extant in 4QXIIg, but not of ובכל.
Am 5:17: Some of verse extant in 4QXIIg, but not of ובכל.
Da 2:38: Some of this verse extant in 4QDana, but not of ובכל.
Eze 5:11: Some of this verse extant in 11QEz, but not of ובכל.
Eze 37:23: Some of this verse extant in MasEzek, but not of ובכל.
This leaves us with a grand total of 11 (yes, 11) places in the DSS where we can see how it was written across the manuscripts.
Ex 9:11: 4QExodc = ובכל
Ex 14:4: Some of verse extant in 4QExodc, but not of ובכל.
4QpaleoExodm = וב[כל] (likely)
Ex 14:17: 4QpaleoGen-Exodi = ובכל
Ex 23:13: 4QpaleoGen-Exodi = [ובכ]ל (likely)
Ex 34:10: 2QExodb = וב[כול] (likely)
Dt 10:12: Some of verse extant in 2QDeutc & 4QpaleoDeutr, but not of ובכל.
4QDeutl = ובכל
1 Sa 14:47: 4QSama =ובכול
Is 7:19: 1QIsaa =ובכול
Some of verse extant in 4QIsae, but not of ובכל.
Is 39:2: 1QIsaa = ובכול
Some of this verse extant in 1QIsab & 4QIsab, but not of ובכל.
Is 49:9 :1QIsaa = ובכול
Some of this verse extant in 1QIsab & 4QIsad, but not of ובכל.
Je 17:19: 4QJera = ובכל
Our statistics are therefore: None-extant: 90; Extant: 11
Definite ובכל: 4
Definite ובכול: 4
Likely ובכל: 2
Likely ובכול: 1
For the places where we have part of the verse, but not all of it, it could be given a possible spelling for ובכל based on the usage of plene/defective spellings in the manuscript. This would require some more time than I feel like we need to give.
The usage is pretty much split, however the defective spelling as ובכל is from four different manuscripts (and likely a fifth); the plene has most in one manuscript (three in 1QIsaa), with only one more with a definite, one with a likely.
(As a note, Steve: you have 1QIsab as having ובכל in Isa 39:2. The manuscript isn't actually extant in that part of the verse; nevertheless, 1QIsab more than likely read ובכל, as the manuscript doesn't use as many plene spellings as 1QIsaa.)
Ste Walch